Are you a pantser or a plotter?
The term “pantser” originally came from the phrase “flying by the seat of your pants,” referring to pilots who used their intuition and senses to fly rather than relying on the instrument panel. When it comes to writers, this term describes those who start their process without a detailed outline, and discover the story as they write. There’s no rigid roadmap. No carefully engineered plan. They just let their imagination meet the blank page.
For some, this feels like artistic purity. To others, it sounds impossible. Can writing through discovery really produce strong narratives without collapsing into confusion?
In this article, I’ll look beneath the label of “pantser” to explore what this form of writing really involves, why some writers are drawn to it, common struggles, and how the natural structure of transformation makes it work.
A “pantser” is a discovery-based writer who eschews detailed outlines to let the story and characters unfold organically through intuition. While this method offers creative freedom and spontaneity, successful narratives still require an underlying structure of character transformation to avoid losing direction.
What is a pantser?
A pantser is a writer who practices writing through discovery, creating their story without mapping every major plot point in advance. Instead of building a detailed outline, the pantser may begin with an image, a voice, a character, or a situation, and allow the narrative to unfold organically.
The pantser writing process usually includes:
- Writing without an outline
- Following character desires rather than a pre-planned plot
- Letting scenes emerge intuitively
- Discovering structure through revision
For the pantser, the writing process can feel mechanical if they know everything ahead of time. Being open to exploration is key. It’s the mystery that comes with pantsing that provides their very momentum to create the story.
Pantser vs Plotter vs Plantser
To understand the pantser more precisely, it is helpful to define the spectrum of writing processes from which it emerges.
- Pantser – Writes to discover. Planning is minimal. Structure emerges as the story moves along.
- Plotter – Outlines extensively. Knows the major turns and maps details extensively before drafting even begins.
- Plantser – This process lands somewhere between the other two. Identifies the key details and turning points but leaves room for discovery and exploration. This is my preferred method, to hold the story loosely as you go and leave it open to change as you learn more about your characters.
Writing does not have to be confined within these terms at all. What matters is that the story carries a genuine transformation.
Story structure is not a formula. It’s the journey of the protagonist, the interaction between characters, and the reframing of false beliefs through the protagonist’s lived experience within the narrative.
Whether you decide to outline or discover, that journey has to take place.
Why writers gravitate toward the pantser method
There are certain shared instincts among writers who identify themselves as pantsers.
- They value surprise.
- They resist rigidity.
- They trust their character to generate plot and momentum.
- They discover clarity by immersing themselves in the story rather than pre-planning.
For some writers, they say outlining drains their energy. If they know the ending or the steps to get there beforehand, the drafting process can feel like transcription instead of creation.
There’s nothing wrong with this process of writing. Many accomplished and successful writers work this way.
The hidden structure beneath discovery writing
Here’s what often goes unspoken: even when you write without an outline, structure is still present.
When a story works, certain details and events occur naturally:
- A protagonist who wants something
- A false belief about what that desire means
- An inciting incident, often a disruption
- Escalating consequences
- A crisis that reveals or exposes the limits of the protagonist’s old identity
- Surrender and acceptance
- A decision or decisive action that directs the narrative toward change
These movements in a story aren’t random. They reflect how a character can transform. A pantser may not outline these stages, but if they aren’t present in a story, the narrative can wander.
Structure isn’t the enemy of intuition. It is the skeleton that allows intuition to stand upright, guiding the protagonist toward transformation.
The real issue: Meaning
The debate surrounding the pantser method usually centers around outlines, but outlines aren’t the heart of a narrative’s structure.
Structure is backed by meaning. To achieve that, you should ask yourself:
- What does my protagonist want?
- What belief shapes that desire?
- When does that belief begin to crack?
- What has to be given up?
- What truth is finally accepted?
The answers to these questions are what help create structure for your story, even if you formed these details through pre-draft outlining or while you were drafting already. Labelling yourself a pantser doesn’t excuse you from studying the transformation of your characters and your story.
Imagine a novelist writing a romance without an outline. Say the goal of the protagonist of the story is to find love. As the narrative progresses, scenes unfold: attraction, conflict, misunderstanding, and attempts at reconciliation. The emotional texture of the story feels alive.
Still, there is a deeper issue that needs to be addressed- the belief that the love of another person will be what makes the protagonist feel complete. If this issue isn’t studied, the story is likely to go in circles.
When the writer comes to recognize that the protagonist has to change or challenge that belief, the story gains direction. Scenes in the narrative can now serve the purpose of testing the protagonist’s identity instead of just staging emotion.
It’s that shift in the story that helps provide structure.
Where pantsers commonly struggle
Writing through discovery and exploration brings a lot of freedom, but this also brings its own risks.
- You can begin to lose direction in the middle of the narrative.
- Scenes can repeat emotional beats without genuine escalation.
- Subplots may contradict developments from earlier in your story.
- Revision can become overwhelming.
The issue here is a lack of clarity when it comes to key factors like the character’s beliefs, what needs to change, or the direction of the story.
If you can’t name those things, even at the beginning, you will probably find your story circling the same emotional terrain without any real movement.
For beginner writers, adapting the pantser method of writing can feel liberating. It removes the pressure of planning and outlining.
But with that sense of freedom, writers need to be wary of the lack of clarity in their story’s direction. It can easily stall early drafts.
For experienced writers, discovery and exploration can help to deepen a narrative’s authenticity. When a writer goes through revision, it’s more structural refinement than anything. Emotional intensity in the story has to align with the transformation that a writer wants to happen.
It’s a writer’s sense of awareness that strengthens their instincts. Discovery writing should move toward transformation. Without that sort of movement, scenes can feel vivid but lack a sense of direction.
Avoiding endless rewrites
Discovery writing usually involves a lot of back and forth between drafting and revising. That isn’t failure, it’s just a part of the process.
To prevent fatigue:
- Pause periodically and take a look at your protagonist’s internal state. Has it shifted?
- The stakes in the story should escalate over time, not repeat.
- After some drafting, take note of what actually happens in the story and mark where your protagonist’s belief changes.
When you approach structure this way, you remove the sense of rigidity and confinement. Structure becomes a way to reflect and find solutions if necessary.
Frequently asked questions
Is being a pantser bad?
No. Each writer has their own process that works for them. Writing through discovery can produce authentic work. It’s when structure is put aside completely that issues can begin to pop up.
Can a pantser finish a novel?
Yes. Many pantsers use reverse outlining to clarify structure after the first draft of their story.
Do professional authors write this way?
Some do. Still, keep in mind that most experienced writers, whether they create a formal outline or not, have developed a strong instinct for story structure, thus it becomes second nature.
Your story weapon: Honoring your instinct
If you believe you are a pantser, honor that instinct. Discovery writing can create stories that are alive, authentic, and deeply personal. It’s the thrill of not knowing what happens next that draws us to the page.
But always keep in mind the key points that shape a story.
- A protagonist wants something.
- That desire is rooted in a belief.
- Experience tests that belief.
- Suffering exposes its limits.
- Through choice or decisive action, a wider perspective emerges.
Whether your writing process involves outlining in detail or writing by the seat of your pants, the goal remains the same. Create a story that guides your character toward transformation.
Structure isn’t rigidity. It simply serves as the quiet architecture beneath that transformation.
If you are a pantser, write boldly. Let your characters live and let the scenes surprise you.
Then take a breath and pause. Ask what has changed, what belief has shifted, what truth has been earned.
If you haven’t identified your protagonist’s false belief or final choice, take a few minutes now and explore it on the page. See where it leads.
Discovery is powerful. Just make sure that your discoveries are moving your protagonist inexorably towards a powerful conclusion for your reader.
If you’re struggling to discover your story and want to be more of a plantser, download a free e-book to get you started on structuring out your story today.
FREE DOWNLOAD—OUTLINE YOUR STORY! Are you struggling with your outline and looking for support? My FREE GUIDE will lead you through the process of marrying the wildness of your imagination to the rigor of story structure to unlock your story within.
